Wednesday, November 10, 2010

vodafone delights (classroom) advertisement review

Vodafone delights (classroom) advertisement

About the company

Vodafone Essar is the Indian subsidiary of Vodafone Group and commenced operations in 1994 when its predecessor Hutchison Telecom acquired the cellular license for Mumbai. The company now has operations across the country with over 115.55 million customers.

About the product

Vodafone delight is exclusive deals and discounts offered by Vodafone to its prepaid and post paid service users. The deals and discounts are offered on variety of products ranging from high end products like Giordano watches and life style items to books, magazines, dining, entertainment and travel.

Advertisement agency

AgencyOgilvy & Mather, India
Film Director
: Prakash Varma, Nirvana Films

Link


About Vodafone Delight campaign
Vodafone India has launched its new service “Vodafone delights” from October, 2010 in a bid to provide benefit of Diwali shopping to its customers. Vodafone is providing deals to its customers not for the recharge this time but on shopping.
Vodafone India is promoting “Delights”, a world of exclusive deals and discounts, with TV advertising campaign featuring school girls in black and white films. These ads are very different from Vodafone’s previous ads such as zoo-zoo and blackberry boys. Till now, the company has issued three advertisements under Vodafone delight. All three advertisements feature same two school girls. The first advertisement is a classroom birthday scene, the second one is a school annual day scene and the third one is an after school cycle scene. All three advertisements show situations from school life which is very common to everyone. “Classroom”, “Cycles” and “Annual Day” show the emotional response associated with receiving special gifts.

Vodafone Delight classroom advertisement storyline
The advertisement opens with a typical classroom setting where a girl is standing in front of the class and all her friends are singing happy birthday for her. The teacher is also standing there and “happy birthday Zoe” is written on the blackboard. The expression on the birthday girl’s face is one of happiness and a little shyness. Then the girl starts to distribute sweets to all her classmates. She gives one sweet to each girl from the box of sweets she is carrying. But when she comes to her friend, she gives her five sweets instead of one. She does not say anything else and moves on. Her friend looks at other girls and feels delighted to get more sweets than others. The ad ends on the happy expression on the friend’s face.
The lines “isn’t it nice when someone makes you feel special?” are then displayed in white on a typical Vodafone red background. The next lines are “enjoy year long privileges with Vodafone Delights” and “join in at  www.vodafone.in”. At last the Vodafone company logo comes with the caption “power to you”.
Throughout the advertisement there is a song playing in the background. The lyrics of the song are -
The little things you do for me and nobody makes me feel good...
The little things you do for me... making me smile and no one else could...
That’s why I like to sit next to you and listen to your mad stories...
I know they are not true and I like that we share a secret or two together... 

Advertisement review


  1. Creativity:   The advertisement is creative in the sense of its use of a simple situation such as classroom birthday party to bring out the emotion of delight one feels when he or she is made feel special.  A classroom birthday scene is a very common scene in advertisement. But the way the ad is depicted with melodious background music and black and white film is unique. The lyrics of the song in the background also help to convey message of happiness, care and closeness. It’s a “feel good” ad. 

2.       Execution: The ad is very well executed. The black and white film with minimum colours used in the ad gives it a different feel. The music in the background is very melodious with guitar and a beautiful voice. There are no dialogues or bright colours used in the ad except the Vodafone red colour. The girls are innocent looking and have acted well. It’s a fine quality ad. The typical red Vodafone background with written lines in white in the end makes the viewer easily connect the ad to Vodafone.

3.       Simplicity: The situation shown in the ad is very simple. There is no fancy storyline, stunts, costumes or concept. Typical classroom setting and sweet looking girls in age group of 10-12 years is all that is shown in the ad and yet it conveys the message of little happiness we all experience on being made feel special. There are no dialogues or even a background voice in the whole ad except a slow melodious song in the background. Also, the brand does not use any celebrity to endorse the service.

4.       Emotional connect: The ad rates high on emotional connect with the viewer. The situation is so common that everyone can relate to it. Your best friend reserving you a place next to her or a few extra chocolates which you got, especially for you on her birthday or getting a ride to home on her bicycle are situations that we all have experienced during our school days. 

5.       Relevance:  The ad is relevant given the brand’s effort to launch new service to its telecom users and depict itself as a caring brand. The new service being offered is related to deals and discounts on various products and services that Vodafone will offer to its customers. The ad is launched at the right time given that people shop maximum during the festive season of Diwali. Vodafone aims to project itself as caring brand which cares for its customers’ little happiness and wants to give back something to them in return for their loyalty.  The lines “isn’t it nice when someone makes you feel special?” and “enjoy year long privileges with Vodafone Delights” in the end convey the message beautifully.

The problem with the ad is that it does not actually tell you much about the product “Vodafone Delights”. It just shows that it feels good to be special and that Vodafone brings similar delight to its customers. It fails to educate the viewer as to what exactly the product/ service is and how can one use it. Given the consumers today care more for benefits, the ad may not prove to be very relevant to the product.
Also, the ad gives just a web address in the end which may make it irrelevant for non internet users.

6.       Memorability: The ad is memorable because of its simplicity and catchy background song. The tune is memorable and can be hummed in leisure time. In my opinion, the viewers will most probably remember the ad and its music, they will also remember that it’s a Vodafone ad but what they may fail to remember is that it’s a “Vodafone Delights” ad.

7.       Comparison to other recent advertisements of telecom service provider:
a.       The idea cellular recently came up with an ad showing Abhishek Bacchan as deaf and dumb who comes with an idea that with help of Idea Cellular network one call translate different languages and talk with anyone. The ad concept is good but not a very different or memorable. Also it does not talk about any additional services that Idea may offer to its users.
b.      Airtel also came up with certain ads with celebrities like Saif- Kareena and Sharman Joshi, and highlighted some of the benefits of using Airtel network. Most of its recent ads are not very memorable.
Hence we may safely assume that for now Vodafone is doing well when compared to its competitor’s ads.

8.       Interest: The ability of the ad to generate interest in the Vodafone Delights is doubtful. The ad does not highlight what exactly Vodafone Delights is or its benefits. Also, after viewing the ad a few times, the viewer may lose interest because of the slowness or lack of humour. The ad lacks humorous punch lines, fancy props or an all together new concept. The advertisement is “sweet” but lacks “newness” which holds interest for long.

9.       Linkage to brand: The advertisement reinforces the positioning of Vodafone as a helpful caring brand.  The ad complements Vodafone’s earlier tagline “happy to help” and current tagline “power to you” which shows consumer centric approach of the brand. The ad depicts Vodafone as brand that will make its customers feel special with its services. The ad also goes well with Vodafone’s earlier ads. We all have seen the classy ads by Vodafone years ago. "Where ever you go, our network follows" first quoted by Hutch, and was later carry forwarded by Vodafone Essar. The pug shown in the ad became a brand icon for Vodafone. This time Vodafone is trying to do something similar by creating ads which could really touch its special customers.

My twist

May be the advertisement could have shown more about the service “Vodafone Delight” itself. It could have better explained what the service actually is, what its benefits to the customers are and how it can be availed.

Conclusion

The overall score I would give to this advertisement is 7/10.
The ad undoubtedly scores high on execution. It’s a fine quality ad with a very nice background song. The adjectives that come to mind after viewing this ad are “sweet” and “simple”.  It strengthens Vodafone’s brand image as a “happy to help” brand.
However, its impact on revenues is doubtful. The service is not much talked about in the ad and the viewer may remain confused as to what exactly is being offered. The viewer may simply remember it as a “nice” Vodafone ad with good music. Given the arrival of festive season, more emphasis should have been made on it providing deals and discounts. Also, all three ads under the Vodafone Delight campaign are of similar kind with same 2 girls in a school environment. The impact of all three is more or less same. It would have been better if different situations were used targeting different consumer groups. The ads may come across as too slow, innocent and girlie to woo all kind of viewers. Hence the ad may prove more be a brand strengthener for Vodafone as a whole than a revenue generator for Vodafone Delights. It’s now for the viewers to explore Vodafone Delights themselves as Vodafone puts it “power to you”!

 

References


cadbury dairy milk shubh arambh advertisement review

Cadbury dairy milk advertisement

About the company

 Cadbury India is a fully owned subsidy of Kraft Foods Inc. It offers snacks, confectionery and quick meals. 

About the product

Cadbury’s Dairy Milk (milk chocolate bar)

Advertisement agency

Oglivy and Mather (directed by Vinil Mathew of Foot Candles).

Link

Advertisement Storyline

The new commercial is set in a middle class housing society, and opens with a middle aged couple stepping out of their house. But all of a sudden, the wife gets nervous and hides behind the door. The husband looks at her in astonishment, to which the wife replies that she cannot step out wearing jeans, as she's worried about what the neighbours and her mother-in-law would say. The husband offers her a cube of cadbury Dairy Milk and tells her that his mother would say to have something sweet before starting a good work, so that the work may end well. The wife takes a bite of the cube and reluctantly smiles at him. The husband then points towards the exit and she timidly steps out with him. Just then, a young neighbour notices her and compliments her. The commercial ends with the woman receiving the compliment with some degree of confidence and pride. The voice over then states, “Shubh Aarambh. Kuch Meetha Ho Jaye.” (Auspicious start. Eat something sweet.)
Shubh Arambh campaign
Cadbury Dairy Milk launched a new campaign, “Shubh Aarambh” ON 2ND July, 2010. This is the second commercial launched by Cadbury Dairy Milk and Ogilvy & Mather under the umbrella of the “Shubh Aarambh” campaign. The campaign is based on the concept of the Indian tradition of having something sweet before every auspicious occasion, with the belief that it leads to a favourable outcome. The first advertisement under this campaign showed a boy having dairy milk before asking a girl out.

Advertisement review

1.       Creativity:  The advertisement is creative in the sense of its ability to connect with the viewers with help of a situation which is very common and yet not captured fully by other advertisers. The settings are typically middle class and the situation is something most of us have seen in their own family, either in the previous generation or in their own generation.  The creativity lies in the ability to bring out positive emotions among the viewers with a simple concept. The advertisement lacks creativity in terms of humour and punch lines.

2.       Execution: Given the situation shown in the advertisement, the execution is well carried out. The setting of a middle class housing society is well suited for such a situation as middle class housewives who live in such society care a lot about what their neighbours might say about them and their family. The neighbours in such societies are often inquisitive and comment if the social norms are broken. The middle aged couple shown in the advertisement looks natural in the situation. Both of them are simply dressed and the wife reflects the hesitation in doing something modern and new. The music in the background is traditional and suits the situation.

3.       Simplicity: The situation shown in the advertisement is very simple. It is the simplicity of the advertisement that strikes the viewers first. There is no fancy storyline, stunts, costumes or concept. Typical middle class housing society setting and middle aged ordinary looking couple is all that is shown in the advertisement and yet its successful in conveying the message of eating something sweet (dairy milk chocolate) for an auspicious start. Also the brand does not use any celebrity in the advertisement unlike its previous ads with Amitabh Bachhan.

4.       Emotional connect: The advertisement rates high on emotional connect with the viewers in the age group of above 20 years. The situation is something we all understand given the nature of Indian society. Middle aged couples will relate to it more than other people and it may not appeal much to kids and teenagers.

5.       Relevance:  The advertisement is relevant given the brand’s effort to shift from a chocolate that’s eaten while celebrating to a chocolate that should be consumed before any auspicious start. The situation shown in the ad has a universal appeal, though it might connect a little better with certain age profiles. It complements the previous commercial under the ad campaign which showed teenagers at a bus stand. So while the 'Bus Stop' may become more popular among youngsters, 'Jeans' might work a little better with the adults.
The ad is relevant given the shubh arambh campaign and “kuch meetha ho jaye” tagline of Dairy Milk. It would help in the effort of the brand to equate chocolates with sweets

6.       Memorability: The memorability of the advertisement may not be very high. The advertisement may strike you when you see it but it may not linger on your mind for long. It lacks humorous punch line, fancy props or an all together new concept. The advertisement is “sweet” but lacks “newness”.
Memorability in comparison to other recent advertisements of chocolates:
In my opinion, some of the advertisements launched by dairy milk’s competitors are more memorable. A recent ad by Nestle’s Kit-Kat shows the dance of two squirrels. Such ads have a greater memorability as they are discussed more often among the peer groups because of their creativity and humour.

7.       Interest: The advertisement may capture interest but not for long. After viewing it a few times, it loses your interest because of its lack of newness of concept or wacky lines. Further youngsters and kids may not relate to it much.

8.       Linkage to brand: The advertisement reinforces the occasion based positioning of Dairy Milk. The brand has been trying to position itself as a symbol of enjoyment and celebrations. Indians have the tradition of sharing sweets on auspicious occasions and on start of a venture. Dairy Milk very cleverly captured this tradition and incorporated into its brand story. The advertisement takes the brand to the core of this tradition linking Dairy Milk to Sweet and auspicious beginning. The advertisement also complements the dairy milk’s tag line of “kuch meetha ho jaye” (lets have something sweet!).

My twist

May be the advertisement could have shown involvement of children in the family as well.  The children and mother in law could have been shown encouraging the woman to go out in jeans. The involvement of children would have helped in connecting with the young viewers. The involvement of mother in law and a few humorous and encouraging lines by her would have added the much required humour. That would have made it a complete family affair.

Conclusion

The overall score I would give to this advertisement is 6.5/10.
The advertisement is simple and would connect well with middle aged population. It goes well with the occasion based positioning of dairy milk and complements the previous ad on youths.  It lacks youthfulness and the ability to maintain interest for long. It is not the kind of ad people discuss and remember for long.
The advertisement would surely help in strengthening the brand image of Dairy Milk. Its impact on sales would have been doubtful any other time of the year but given the arrival of festive season, the effort to equate chocolate with “meetha” (sweets) may bear fruits. Dairy milk is not only a chocolate for kids but adults alike. It can be given as a gift on occasions such as diwali. Hence the impact of this advertisement should be positive. “shumbh arambh. Kuch meetha ho jaye”!

 

References